Valuemind

The NOI that looked good on old data

Income-based pricing at ₹2.70 crore looked solid until rental comps were updated. Karthik Anand’s valuation needed vacancy adjustments and HVAC aging that old data ignored.

Image

Current market data changed the income math

Vacancy rates and aging revealed NOI built on yesterday’s rents.

₹25 lakh

Saved by updating outdated rental comps to current rates

88%

Income projection accuracy vs. seller’s NOI claims

2.8×

Negotiation power with updated lease data

In Salt Lake, rental comps age faster than sellers admit

 

Old Data

Rental comps 2 years old market had shifted.

 

Vacancy Gap

Projections assumed full occupancy actual 15-18% vacant.

 

Building Costs

HVAC and façade aging capital expenses not factored.

 

Investment Need

Law firm needed real income, not inflated projections

What Changed Karthik Anand’s Valuation

We stepped in with a simple, facts-first 3-step process:


  • feature-icon
    Market Research

    Updated lease comparables to current Salt Lake commercial rates.
    Found rental assumptions were 2 years stale and overstated income.

  • feature-icon
    Occupancy Reality

    Normalized for vacancy and concessions reducing effective rental income.
    Documented 15-18% vacancy vs. seller’s zero-vacancy projection.

  • feature-icon
    Capital Costs

    Adjusted NOI for building aging HVAC and façade upgrade needs.
    Delivered ₹2.40–₹2.48 cr removing inflated income assumptions.

How Rental Data Reset Valuation

Zero-vacancy assumptions and outdated comps failed when current occupancy patterns and building costs entered income analysis.

 

Market Truth

Current lease rates revealed income inflation from old data.

Income-Based Price

Delivered ₹2.40–₹2.48 cr with realistic projections.

Features

The NOI Analysis That Reset Valuation

Seller quoted commercial office PPSF. Industrial specification breakdown revealed warehouse features that justified different valuation.

feature-icon

Market Research

Updated rental comps to current Salt Lake rates.


Research Market

feature-icon

Occupancy Reality

Adjusted for actual vacancy patterns in market.


Check Reality

feature-icon

Lease Incentives

Factored concessions into effective rent calculations.


Factor Incentives

feature-icon

System Aging

Identified HVAC upgrade costs within 3-5 years.


Check Aging

feature-icon

Building Condition

Assessed façade maintenance impact on NOI.


Assess Condition

feature-icon

Fair NOI

Delivered ₹2.40–₹2.48 cr removing income inflation.


Get Fair Value

Image
Image Dark

“As a law firm, we were buying for investment income. The seller’s NOI used 2-year-old rental comps and assumed full occupancy. Current lease data showed ₹25 lakhs less income potential when vacancy and building aging were factored.”

—Karthik Anand

Law Firm Partner, Salt Lake

Our insights

Customer Success Stories


View all case studies

Every property hides something

Hidden costs. Wrong benchmarks. Layout gaps. We expose pricing errors.


Expose Gaps

2